David
Lockspeiser writes
that he and John Gale set off in September 1959 to visit the Hunter
users of the Middle East and India, starting in Jordan...
The Jordanians were very sharp under the excellent leadership of Erik
Bennet, an RAF exchange Squadron Leader. Flying in low level battle
formation with them over the Dead Sea I saw minus 1100ft on my
altimeter; unusual. The Lebanese didn't benefit from the same quality
of RAF representation so were short on operating procedures as well as
spares; there was more of a flying club atmosphere. I had been to Iraq
the previous year to give an armament demonstration to King Fiesal. He
was assassinated only a few weeks later - only eighteen, poor chap -
when Khasim led a cruel Communist revolution; so we weren't going
there. It wasn't until after another revolution in May 1963 that Alf
Black (a great chap; does anyone know if he is still around?) and I
went back in G-APUX and stayed to do conversion training.
Burmese Sea
Fury Incidents
We next visited our last port of call, we thought; John with
the
engineers and I with the pilots at Ambala and Poona, India. They had
some problems but they were mostly interested in having spinning
demo's. I remember staying in a hotel on Bombay which had a
large wrought iron arch above the entrance with a notice
stating:
"Dogs and South Africans Not Admitted." Also they had an alcohol ban
(of all places to have one!). When I went to the bar before dinner,
staffed by a barman and an armed policeman, I was told I could only
have a drink if I got a permit from the police station stating that I
was an alcoholic. So I accepted the challenge and eventually got a
drink. The sad thing is I've lost this magnificent document; green and
about half as large again as A4. It was while in India that we got the
message from Stranks and JTL (John Lidbury) of problems with the
Burmese Sea Furys. We managed to get a flight and bummed a ride on a
BOAC crew bus to Palam airport, arriving at Rangoon some hours later.
It was October 20th 1959.
The
Burmese Air Force
had grounded their Sea Furies after suffering a number of fatalities
without any clue as to the cause of these seemingly mysterious
accidents. Hawkers, I think, had an agent there but it was the Air
Attache, Grp Capt Teddy Pippet, who gave us a full briefing and
provided an enormous amount of help and hospitality over the whole
period. He took us to see Clift, the CAS, and a senior staff officer,
Saw Pru, who gave us carte blanche to do whatever was necessary to get
the Furys airborne again. As it happened I knew Saw Pru as we had both
been on the same RAF course at Leconfield in 1952.
We were driven out to the Air Force base at Hmawbi, discussed
the
accidents with the Squadron Commander, looked at the remains of a Fury,
and got an engineer to translate the court of enquiry report on UB469.
The accidents all had one thing in common; none of the pilots uttered a
sound, let alone a word, and it seemed most likely that they were
either dead or unconscious before the aircraft hit the ground. Most
crashed in paddy fields and we were taken by Piaseki helicopter to
UB464's crash site where there was no evidence at all, except from the
large and vocal local farming community who pointed to an area of the
paddy and said it was "down there." Two villagers said there was a
bang, black smoke and a small fire; some said it was smoking when it
crashed.
My diary note records,
"I think it
possible that petrol fumes from a loose pipe or filter started a fire -
fumes and smoke entered the cockpit causing unconsciousness of pilot."
Bristols had an engine rep. out there and we worked together on that
assumption. On the fourth day John received a message to return to
India as soon as he was able, to help with investigating a recent fatal
Hunter accident there.
It
seemed most likely that
the cause of these Fury accidents was from carbon monoxide poisoning,
and further evidence for that theory was the very poor state of
servicing; oil and hydraulic leaks, missing panel fasteners and poor
safety (not really an appropriate word) equipment. From the cockpit air
intake in the starboard wing root, air passed an oil union which, if
loose, could add to the problem. They did not use oxygen (didn't fly
high enough - unquote) and some oxygen masks were attached with a
safety pin. The senior engineering officer, a nice fellow, had a
supernumerary job as messing officer, a task which he carried out with
great diligence at the local meat and vegetable markets.
The pilots were clearly apprehensive about the thought of
getting
into the air again, augmented by another cause that I learned about
with a certain amount of dismay. The pilots had consulted a Phongyi
(soothsayer) who put the fear of hell into them by saying the accidents
were caused by the ghosts of dead pilots. Some pilots showed interest
in their aircraft, but little by most and least of all by the Squadron
Commander who seemed to spend most of his time playing Mahjong.
The plan of action was to get the aircraft comprehensively
serviced, not once, but twice using separate teams. The oxygen system
was to be made operational and all other safety equipment carefully
inspected. Rangoon University was contacted to get some evacuated
flasks with which to take samples of cockpit air. This worked well and
three enthusiastic, learned gents, with a PhD and MSc, from the
chemistry department, arrived. It took them a bit longer than I had
hoped so, before they returned, I did some flying on UB456 after the
servicing programme had been carried out. When they did it was not only
with evacuated flasks but also with crystals and CO sensitive paper
with which I could decorate the cockpit. UB456 was the aircraft picked
for the job, and also 454 when the professors who had really entered
into the spirit of things, turned up again some days later, with even
more evacuated flasks.
There
was no change of
colour on the paper or in the crystals and the results from the
University of these tests which, with drop tanks fitted, consisted of a
sightseeing tour of southern Burma, Rangoon, the Gulf of Martaban up
country, and around the bay of Bengal, were that there was a very small
amount of CO present, not dangerous, and the content did not vary
between samples taken at the beginning, the middle or the end of the
flight.
On the 26th I visited
the War Office and
persuaded them to lift the flying ban on four single- and one
two-seater, which had all been fully serviced and which I had flown and
cleared. As I feared this was not met with much enthusiasm at the
squadron, to whom I gave a lecture, air and ground crew, explaining the
cause of the accidents, stressing the importance of following
procedures, both technical and operational, and trying to inject some
confidence. I felt sorry for these lads who mostly came from a rural
background and had only flown piston Provosts, as I recall, and had not
had the benefit which we all have of being brought up with things
mechanical, so, not surprisingly, they could be easily intimidated by
an aircraft with the potency of the Fury. Earlier I had offered to fly
the youngest pilot, who had ten hours on the Fury, in a T.20, but he
was not keen. I'm sure he would have been had the leadership he
experienced been different.
The
Air Staff had, of
course, been kept aware of all that was going on, and I submitted a
report of recommendations which Teddy Pippet had typed for me, and
which they said they would action. They did fly their Furys again and
had a section of four airborne over Rangoon, but not all that long
after they swapped fixed for rotary wings.