On 11th November
Harry
Fraser-Mitchell kindly stepped in at the last minute to give this
lecture when John Parker, who was to talk on BAE Systems heritage
matters, had at short notice to go to the USA. The audience certainly
did not lose by the substitution.
Barry
Pegram
introduced Harry by saying he needed no introduction because he was so
well known for his aerodynamics work at Kingston and as a founder
Member of the Association. But before that he had worked for Handley
Page (HP) for many years and is still a leading member of the Handley
Page Association. He came to Hawker when the Company closed. There were
many similarities, said Harry, between the two companies, including
their size and the fact that they both had innovative charismatic
leaders - Handley Page and Camm.
Harry started
with the origins of the Company. Frederick Handley Page was born in
1885 in Cheltenham to Frederick Joseph Page, who owned and ran an
upholstery business, and Ann Elizabeth, nee Handley. From Cheltenham
Grammar School young Frederick went to London and enrolled at the
Finsbury Technical College where he studied electrical engineering and
became interested in aircraft.
Handley
Page, Sixty Years Of Achievement: 1909 - 1970
On
graduation he joined an electrical machinery manufacturer at
Woolwich. He continued to study aviation, built flying models and
manned gliders, collaborated with other pioneers and eventually, in
1909, set up his own company, Handley Page Ltd , at Creekmouth,
Barking. This was the first limited company established for the design
and manufacture of aircraft.
Moving on to HP’s aircraft Harry
described the HP Type A monoplane, the Bluebird, of 1910. This employed
the patent, crescent shaped wing, devised by artist-engineer Jose
Weiss, based on his study of soaring eagles, to which HP added wing
warping for lateral control. The Bluebird not entirely successful even
after modification to the type C, and was abandoned.
The Type D
development fared better but real success came with the tandem two seat
Type E, the ‘Yellow Peril’ of 1912, and the side-by-side two seat type
F of 1913. Sadly Lt Wilfred Parke, RN, was killed in the latter when
the engine failed in windy conditions resulting in a stall and
incipient spin. In 1912 GR Volkert joined HP as Chief Designer, staying
with the company until 1948.
With the RFC banned from flying
monoplanes HP turned to biplanes resulting in his 1913 tandem two seat
Type G 100, retaining the crescent wing planform. The large type L 200
with dual controls and side-by-side seats in a closed cabin was
designed to compete for the Daily Mail £1,000 prize for a non-stop
flight across the Atlantic. It was built not flown due to the advent of
World War I.
The subsequent O/100 and
O/400 twin engined heavy bombers
served the RFC well, some 550 O/400s being built. The even larger four
engined V/1500 with Rolls-Royce Eagles in tandem pairs did not fly
until May 1918 so was just too late to see action, but served with the
RAF post-war.
On HP’s birthday a V/1500
flew forty people round London,
presaging the many civil transport conversions and variants of the
O/400, the W series, used in the 1920s. HP himself formed Handley Page
Transport Ltd to operate civil O/400s.
A
new transport design, the
O/700 or O7, retained the main components of the O/400 adapted to civil
use, and the W8 was a purpose designed airliner. In turn the Hyderabad
bomber was a W8 with a new fuselage. Variants also included trimotor
airliners and the Hinaidi RAF transport. The all-metal Hinaidi II led
to all subsequent HP production aircraft using this method of
construction. The W10 airliner was derived from the Hyderabad at short
notice for Imperial Airways as they found themselves unexpectedly short
of capacity.
At this point
Harry diverted from his ‘types’ route
to talk about the Handley Page slot. Dr Gustav Lachman was
co-discoverer of the aerodynamic slot with HP and was employed by HP as
a consultant from 1921 - 24 and, after a spell in Japan, joined the
company in 1929 where he held the positions of Experimental Designer,
Chief Designer and Director of Research when he did much work on the
boundary layer and laminar flow. Lachman held the German patents for
the slot, HP the British. After wind tunnel testing, which showed a 50%
lift increase, a fixed slot was fitted to a DH9 (HP17) which
demonstrated flight at 38 mph.
The HP39
Gugnunc slotted biplane was
designed to enter the Daniel Guggenheim Fund’s Safe Aircraft
Competition. The two finalists were the Gugnunc and the winning Curtiss
Tanager, fitted with slots in contravention of the HP patents. After a
legal battle Curtiss admitted infringement. The automatic retractable
slot development reduced drag in the cruise. In 1928 the HP slot was
adopted for all RAF aircraft and was widely used elsewhere including by
the US Navy, and the resulting royalties were a significant portion of
HP’s revenue.
In the years
leading up to World War II the
Company built the famous and luxurious but slow four-engined biplane
HP42 Hannibal class airliner for Imperial Airways, which proved a
money-spinner for them on European and Empire air routes. The curious
HP50 Heyford twin-engined biplane bomber had its fuselage and engine
nacelles attached under the upper wing with a gap between the fuselage
and the lower wing, a layout which gave reduced drag and a better field
of fire for the defensive guns when compared with the conventional
layout. The monoplane twin-engined HP54 Harrow bomber with Lachman’s
cantilever wing and a fixed undercarriage was adopted by the RAF as a
rapidly producible stop-gap type pending the availability of the more
advanced bombers in the pipe line.
For the war HP produced the
slender and fast Hampden twin engined bomber and torpedo carrier, with
its ingenious ‘pod and boom’ fuselage devised by Lachman, and the
outstanding Halifax bomber. This was initially designed for two R-R
Vulture engines (HP56) but because of probable delays in the
engine
programme four R-R Merlins were substituted to give the HP57. The
aircraft was produced in many bomber Mks in both Merlin and Bristol
Hercules powered versions, the latter being the more successful with
some 6,000 built, and as military and, eventually, civil
transports by
conversion to Halton standard. The HP75 Manx twin engined tail-less
research aircraft, conceived by Lachmann as a low drag configuration,
but developed by Godfrey Lee, suffered from an extended development
period and did not result in the hoped-for rear gun turret equipped
bomber defender.
After the war
the HP67 Hastings military
transport, utilising Halifax wings, was the mainstay of RAF Transport
Command and the HP81 Hermes IV, with pressurised cabin and tricycle
undercarriage, designed to a BOAC specification which included
hot-and-high operations, flew with that airline only until 1954 and
thereafter successfully with independent operators on freighting and
package holidays. Two Bristol Theseus turboprop powered Hermes Vs were
also test flown but the engine was not a success.
In 1947
Godfrey Lee had proposed a swept wing, high altitude jet bomber, with
wingtip fins and a small tail unit, which gave rise to OR 230 and was
the basis for his revolutionary Victor. In 1951 construction of two
Armstrong Siddeley Sapphire powered HP80 (Victor) prototypes started,
the first flying in December 1950. The Victor was the fastest of the
‘V’ bombers, was supersonic in a shallow dive and could carry the
largest bomb load (35 X 1000 lb bombs vs. 21 in the Vulcan) Innovations
included the crescent wing good for a level .875M and ensuring control
at the stall, leading edge flaps, fully variable air brakes and the ‘T’
tail, an early application of this flawed configuration.
The Mk2 Victor
was powered by R-R Conways although HP wanted Bristol’s Olympus but
these were earmarked for Vulcans. At the end of their bombing career
Victors were converted to tankers by HSA and played an important role
in the Falklands war.
A military
freighter version, the HP111, was
winner of an RAF strategic lift competition but Sir Frederick would not
submit to Government pressure to amalgamate his company with HSA or
BAC, so the order went to the Short Belfast. The HP115 was a very
slender delta designed to explore the low speed handling qualities of
such configurations. In thirteen years it made some thousand flights
with the RAE at Bedford.
Sir
Frederick died in 1962 with his
famous Company still independent. Afterwards came the HP137 Jetstream.
This was designed to fill a gap perceived in the US commuter market.
Powered by two Turbomeca Astazous of 840 hp it proved underpowered so
was certified at a reduced all-up weight with rather poor range/payload
performance. Before the more powerful Series 200 could be
certified
the Company failed and a pending USAF order for a Garrett powered
version was lost.
However, a consortium
of ex-HP people bought the
Jetstream design rights and airframes and certified the Srs 200.
Scottish Aviation subsequently took over and received an order for RAF
and RN trainers and went on to develop a Garrett powered version.
Successful development and substantial sales success continued when
Scottish Aviation became part of British Aerospace.
Harry then
explained why Sir Frederick never agreed to a merger. In his talks with
HSA in 1960 HP asked 16/- per share from HSA when the market price was
13/-; HSA offered 10/- which HP turned down. At this point the
Government cancelled 28 Victor BMk2s so HSA reduced their offer to
about 8/- when the shares were trading at 10/-. Now the RAF selected
the Herald rather than HSA’s Avro 748 but the Government would not pay
HP their full Victor contract cancellation claim and the merger talks
collapsed. Next HSA offered 5/- which was rejected, the
Government
cancelled the Herald order and the Company went into receivership. A US
company, the Cravens Corporation, took over but not long after the
owner died and the business collapsed.
Turning to research Harry
described: laminar flow (LF) control work using a suction gloved
Vampire, on which full chord LF was achieved, and a swept scale wing
mounted vertically on a Lancaster (now in the Battle of Britain
Memorial Flight); the proposed HP113 commuter jet; and the HP130, a
proposed LF wing conversion on an HS125. Wind tunnel tests were
promising but the Ministry would not fund full scale flight tests.
On production development the Hampden pioneered dispersed
production
and photo lofting allowed the making of the necessary multiple
identical jigs. Corrugated sandwich skin was a manufacturing innovation
on the Victor wing. On test facilities HP had a huge test frame capable
of taking a Victor, carried out model flutter testing using German
techniques, and a centrifuge for testing such things as partially
filled drop tanks. Harry thought the latter was not very useful, but
the Ministry had paid for it; Sir Frederick used to tell his people
that he wanted “their heads in the clouds, their feet on the ground,
and their hands in the pockets of the Ministry.”
On projects
Harry mentioned Chief Designer Volkert’s 1937 idea for an inexpensive,
numerous, small, fast, unarmed bomber which could outrun fighters and
so operate with impunity by day or night. This philosophy was rejected
by the RAF and the RAE and was shelved. However Air Marshal Sir William
Freeman resuscitated the idea and it was pursued by de Havilland as the
Mosquito.
The HP100 was a Mach 2+ canard
reconnaissance bomber project,
there was a blended wing short range ‘airbus’ and the HP117 was an
all-wing , laminar flow airliner offering a 30% decrease in cost per
mile. The latter concept is receiving renewed interest today.
In
conclusion Harry summarised HP’s major achievements which included: HP
was first Ltd Company established in the UK specifically for the design
and construction of aircraft; mass production of large bombers in WWI;
development of the slot for wings and flaps; range of successful
airliners in the ’20s; dispersed production techniques; over 1,500
Hampdens and 6,000 Halifaxes built; 150 Hastings built; the best ‘V’
bomber; the Jet stream (in other hands); and finally a record 86 years
of continuous service with the RAF.