Originally published in ‘Harrier Communique’ No.8, Winter 1974.
I was particularly frightened. Robbie Roberts (HSA
Kingston Sales Executive) knew it too - he was with me at the time
I was trying to get on board the Indian Navy Carrier
Vikrant. The
weather was not too bad; there was low cloud and at low level the
visibility was decidedly murky, only about a mile in a humid
sub-tropical haze over the sea. In a Harrier of course, as we always
say, you can slow down and visibility on the approach to land is
nothing like the problem to a Harrier pilot as it is to the pilot of a
normal high performance jet. Alas, at the time, Robbie and I were not
in a Harrier but in an Indian taxi, streaking through the narrow
crowded streets of Bombay’s dockland. The cause of my fear was that on
several occasions the young lad driving us used only the horn when I
was absolutely certain that operation of the steering wheel and brakes
was needed.
Once on the ship, though, we were quickly engrossed
in details of
planning the Harrier operations which were to take place eight weeks
later. A meeting was held with the ship’s officers and the engineering,
administrative and flying control aspects were quickly dealt with. All
that remained was a period on the flight deck where it was decided what
markings would be painted on the deck. In the end we settled for a
centre line two feet wide down the axial length of the deck, a white
line across the bows of the ship for the ‘nozzles down’ cue and a
dotted line down the starboard side of the deck, parallel with the
centre line, for use as a ‘wing tip safety line’ behind which all
parked aircraft, men and equipment would be positioned while a short
take-off (STO) was in progress. More of these lines later as ideas
about them turned out to be a most important new aspect resulting from
the subsequent flying.
First
Two-Seater Harrier Exercise On A Ship
By John Farley
The Harrier to be used was the Hawker Siddeley owned two seat
demonstrator registered G-VTOL. It was fitted with the Rolls-Royce
Pegasus 11, the 21500 lb thrust engine currently in service with the
RAF and USMC Harriers. It was to be the first time that the longer and
heavier two-seater had been flown from a ship. Therefore, in our
meetings with the Indian Navy, Robbie and I had been at some pains to
point out that we only had estimates of our performance from Vikrant
and that it would require cautious test flying, rather than a simple
sales demonstration, allowing us to establish what weights we could
lift from what deck runs in the hot monsoon conditions off the Indian
coast in July.
The ferry flight to India was uneventful, the route
being Dunsfold, Naples, Akrotiri, Tehran, Kuwait, Masirah, Bombay. The
ground crew followed along each leg in a Hawker Siddeley 748. In Bombay
the team met the monsoons, an intensity of rainfall that someone used
to shopping in Woking cannot be expected to comprehend. Sufficient to
say that although the Harrier arrived at Bombay only 20 minutes late on
the plans laid two months earlier, we were a day late arriving at
Cochin, the Indian Navy base on the south west tip of India. The delay
meant that the two days allowed for work-up flying from the airfield
prior to going on board Vikrant had to be shrunk to a single day. I
didn’t mind this but it was hard on Captain Tahiliani, the Director of
Air Staff Division, Indian Navy, who was to fly in the rear seat. Since
the Captain had not previously flown the Harrier it meant that he had
to train very intensively to reach the standard necessary for him to
control the aircraft himself in the confined environment of the deck.
The morning of the first day allocated to the ship
dawned hot and humid but fine and the short flight out to the ship with
a vertical landing (VL) on the stern was completely straightforward.
Due to the test flying aspects of the initial take-offs it had been
agreed that I would fly the aircraft solo the first day and Captain
Tahiliani and two other officers would join in on the second day.
Examination of the deck markings showed that they
had been painted just where I had asked for them but unfortunately the
two foot wide centre line, down which the Harrier would roll, was in
high gloss paint which was very slippery indeed when it was wet. Since
the Harrier is controlled directionally by nose wheel steering it was
clear I would have to run slightly to one side of this line. This
caused some concern at first since the obstacle clearance on the left
hand side with the Harrier on the line was only 8 ft 6 ins. Running to
the right of the line would have taken the wing tip uncomfortably close
to parked aircraft. However, there was an additional line already
painted on the deck 7 ft to the left of the Harrier line and parallel
with it so it appeared that providing the Harrier operated between
these two lines all would be well. This was how the matter was left and
after a short period of taxying round the deck to familiarise the deck
handlers with the Harrier I was all set for the first take-off. This
was done at a light weight down the full length of the 660 ft axial
deck.
The technique used for the first short take-off
(STO) worked well and was retained in principle throughout the two days
flying. It consisted of taxying the Harrier into position at the start
of the run, running the Pegasus up to 55% RPM with the brakes on and
the nozzles almost aft at 8 deg down. Then, on being given clearance to
take-off, the brakes were released, full throttle applied and the left
hand moved from the throttle to the nozzle lever as the run commenced.
The aircraft was kept straight with the nose wheel steering controlled
by the rudder bar and then finally, when the white line at the end of
the deck reached the bottom of the windscreen, the nozzles were lowered
to the required angle marked by the preset STO stop. There followed a
short period off the end of the deck when I reflected how lucky naval
aviators are not having to bother to climb over anything from hedges,
trees and houses up to hills and mountains, as pilots flying from
airfields usually do.
Vertical landings (VL) with a Harrier are very
straightforward because any approach path errors (slightly high, low,
left, right, too slow, too fast etc) can be corrected after the
aircraft has come to the hover, whereas in a conventional aircraft the
pilot carries these errors with him right to touchdown. In fact the
Harrier is so much easier in this regard that one has to remind oneself
continually to stay alert and not relax because it is so
straightforward.
I digress; back to the Vikrant. After this sortie a
second was done at the same light weight to allow me to feel certain I
had got used to the deck technique and then the weight was increased by
putting more fuel into the Harrier. The third take-off was with full
internal fuel, the fourth through to the eighth were all at full
internal fuel but the distance of the start point from the end of the
deck was reduced down to as little as 370 ft. The remaining take-offs
on the first day were with the Harrier as heavy as we could make it
using fuel alone and for these the two 100 gall combat drop tanks were
full (approximately 1600 lb extra weight). The run was eventually
reduced at this maximum weight to 585 ft. On the eleventh flight the
aircraft was landed back at Cochin for the night with the whole
Hawker-Rolls team as well as our Indian hosts well pleased with the
day’s activities.
The second day’s flying saw Captain Tahiliani flying
in the rear cockpit for the first six flights. He had no difficulty in
taking control of the Harrier outside the hangar at Cochin and flying
entirely unaided into a hover astern of Vikrant 20 minutes later. This,
of course, illustrated why Hawker chose a two seater for the
demonstrator. We say the Harrier can be flown by any pilot trained on
modern military jets but people still tend to doubt it until they try
it for themselves.
By the end of his six flights on the second day
Captain Tahiliani had flown a take-off himself on the full length of
the axial deck and had accompanied me on the first angled deck take-off
using the short 377 ft deck length. In addition I demonstrated a
cross-deck VL just aft of the island to show the technique used when
landing a Harrier if the ship is not steaming into wind. Captain
Tahiliani then gave up his seat to Cdr Grewal, the Commander (Air) of
the Vikrant. Cdr Grewal being a current Sea Hawk and helicopter pilot
found himself delighted with the Harrier, carrying out a decelerating
transition alongside the ship followed by an accelerating transition
back to wingborne flight, with no assistance from me other than the odd
word of encouragement over the intercom. The three remaining flights
that day were with Cdr Raju, a Sea Hawk Squadron Commander, in the rear
seat. On these flights we covered a VTO from the bow of the ship and a
heavy weight STO from the 310 ft point. This particular take-off
allowed those on the bridge and in flying control the novel experience
of looking down into the cockpit of a modern aeroplane about to do a
free take-off from a point over half way down the deck. It resulted in
many “I just don’t believe it” comments.
I mentioned earlier about the deck markings and the
ideas that resulted from the Vikrant operations. The conclusion of the
Indian Navy officers at the end of the Harrier flying was that the
Harrier needed a total operating strip no wider than 38 ft 6 ins (I
talked them into this; they wanted to reduce it by 6 ft!). If this
strip was positioned down the port side of the ship it left another
strip over 30 ft wide down the starboard side for parked and taxying
aircraft as well as equipment.
Thus, because of the Harrier’s good control on
take-off and the small space needed to do a simple vertical landing,
the concept of an angled deck is no longer important for the Harrier.
This has two effects: it simplifies the design of new ships to straight
decks and it enables a much wider range of hitherto obsolescent
aircraft carriers around the world to become ideal homes for Harriers,
offering a wide range of fixed wing roles at sea with unapproachably
low levels of capital investment.
The exercise finished as planned at the end of the
second day. The two days with Vikrant had given us 21 sorties at an
ambient temperature of 30 deg C. The surface wind was almost calm at a
maximum of 3 kts and the wind over deck much less than one would
normally expect. Despite these ambient penalties the Harrier had once
again shown to a potential customer that not only can our brochure
performance figures be met, with some margin in hand, but also that the
aeroplane can be handled by existing military jet pilots with little
special training.
Editor’s note. Eric Crabbe was the flight test
engineer on the trial. The parallel line deck markings that had
happened serendipitously were found to be much easier to track during
take-off than a single centre line, which prompted the pilot to make
unnecessary small corrections, so were adopted as standard for Harrier
carriers. This 1973 demonstration eventually resulted in the FRSMk51
Sea Harrier being ordered by the Indian government in 1979, the first
of 30 being delivered in December 1983. The last FRSMk51s were retired
in 2016 after 33years of service.